A publication of the Washington Baltimore Center for Psychoanalysis

Share This Post

Book Review: “Racist States of Mind”

By Isabelle Babcock, PhD
Member, The Washington Center for Psychoanalysis
April 2017 | Volume 4 | Issue 4

This past fall, feeling overwhelmed by the increasing expressions of racist hatred in the United States and abroad, I read Neranda Keval’s book, “Racist States of Mind: Understanding the Perversion of Curiosity and Concern.”

Dr. Keval’s argument is that persons in a racist state of mind “are stuck in a nostalgic haze about an idealized past,” which seems lost forever. Racism thrives when this profound sense of loss is experienced as a destroyed sense of individual and group identity. This loss is fueled by a severe sense of grievance, betrayal, and powerlessness, which activates murderousrageandfantasiesofrevenge. Theethnicotherbecomesatargetwhose function is to serve as a recipient for the racist’s unbearable sense of having lost something vital. By attacking the ethnic identity of the other, the racist throws the other’s “sense of self into profound doubt.” The denigration of the other’s identity allows the racist to displace his own experience of feeling destroyed into another.

Furthermore, Keval explains that this toxic interplay of grievance, murderous rage and vengeful fantasies inevitably results in destruction of curiosity and concern. The excitement derivedfromhurtinganotherfurtherentrenchesthisprocess. Hebelievesthatrestoring curiosity and concern is the only way to weaken the grip of the racist mindset. One has to move from being stuck in “an idealized past” to mourn what has been lost and be open to new experiences. The racist mindset, as described by Keval, is a dynamic typical of individuals who feel weakened and who, therefore, cannot trust their resilience when faced with loss and the unknown.

Dr. Keval’s book is sobering: this psychological process is pervasive and insidious. In the consulting room and in our everyday life we are challenged to resist the onslaught of racist attacks without retaliating in kind or losing our curiosity and concern for the other.

Explore more in PsychBytes


A favorite amusement during my elementary-school years was a puzzle-map of the United States. The puzzle pieces comprised all the states. The top of the puzzle went beyond the USA halfway up Canada, and the bottom ended halfway through Mexico.

Mad or Sad?

Here I am, taking comfort in the sunroom and emailing off another cartoon to my sister. I have two sisters and have always been especially close to sister number two, Patti. It could be said that we are close because we are nearer in age, but really, we are close because we are pretty much on the same wavelength. We enjoy a lot of the same things including guffawing over clever memes. We like to laugh.

Content Edit Request

Please submit one request at a time.