PsychBytes

A publication of the Washington Baltimore Center for Psychoanalysis

Matisse "Dance" (1910) Moscow, The Hermitage Museum

Share This Post

“Pagan” or Sublime?

J. David Miller, MD
Member, Washington Baltimore Center for Psychoanalysis
April 2026 | Volume 9 | Issue 9

When the curtain rises on Brian Friel’s renowned play, “Dancing at Lughnasa,” Michael, a pleasant young man, addresses the audience as though he’s lying on an analyst’s couch: “When I cast my mind back to that summer of 1936, different kinds of memories offer themselves to me.” He was only seven, but the memories still make him “uneasy;” it was a time of “things changing too quickly.” These memories unfold for us on the stage.

In Michael’s Irish village, it is the time of Lughnasa, the Celtic harvest festival, a “pagan” celebration centered on communal dancing. Michael hears that devout Catholics scorn it as a rampage by “savages” from “the black hills.” He sees his mother, Chris, and her four sisters erupt in a pagan-like dance of “near-hysteria” when the radio plays a stirring tune, but when the music stops, they stop suddenly and seem ashamed.

However, as Michael says, it was a time of “things changing.” His missionary uncle, Father Jack, newly returned from Africa, exalts the ecstatic dancing of pagan “ceremonies.” As the love-child of Chris and Gerry, Michael watches his roving father when he comes to visit: “For the first time in my life, I had a chance to observe him.” He sees his parents dancing in tender silence, “as if language had surrendered to movement.” Though no priest had blessed their sexual union, their dance seems to sanctify it. As Friel has said, “there’s a need for the pagan in life…I don’t think of it as disrupting Christianity.”

Friel presents the “pagan,” in ceremonial or romantic dancing, as potentially spiritual, a sublimation of the instinctual. He had no analytic training or treatment, and when asked about Freud, he said only, “I’ve read some,” yet he was able to read himself and the people in his life remarkably well.

Explore more in PsychBytes

Shortcut

I live in the city and often walk to my preferred destinations. Sometimes my walks include shortcuts when going to familiar places. One common shortcut was an alley which contained rats.

While the rats were disturbing and seemingly everywhere, I continued using my shortcut.  At some point an intervention occurred – poison.  I began to experience the mixed blessing of dying rats instead of living rats.  While I hesitated to look at the dead and decaying rats, they were in my path and I couldn’t ignore them.  In time, the living rats disappeared. But at the end of my alley shortcut, “my inner rats” remained alive in the office of my psychoanalyst.

“Pagan” or Sublime?

When the curtain rises on Brian Friel’s renowned play, “Dancing at Lughnasa,” Michael, a pleasant young man, addresses the audience as though he’s lying on an analyst’s couch: “When I cast my mind back to that summer of 1936, different kinds of memories offer themselves to me.” He was only seven, but the memories still make him “uneasy;” it was a time of “things changing too quickly.” These memories unfold for us on the stage.

Content Edit Request

Content Edit Request

Please submit one request at a time.